Progress Chart[]
| Rank | Guest | Photo | Role | Ep. 1 | Ep. 2 | Ep. 3 | Ep. 4 | Ep. 5 | Ep. 6 | Ep. 7 | Ep. 8 | Ep. 9 | Ep. 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Survivors (Winners) | Joey Graceffa | 
|
The Savant | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | CRSD/2nd | SAFE | HOST |
| Roi Fabito | 
|
The Daredevil | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | DEAD | RESR + SAFE |
CRSD/1st | SAFE | WINNER | ||
| Safiya Nygaard | 
|
The Investigate Reporter |
SAFE | HELP | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | VOTE | SAFE | VOTE | WINNER | |
| 2nd | Rosanna Pansino | 
|
The Jet-Setter | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | VOTE | SAFE | VOTE | CRSD/3rd | DEAD | |
| 3rd | Colleen Ballinger | 
|
The Disco Dancer | SAFE | HELP | SAFE | VOTE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | DEAD | ||
| 4th | Matthew Patrick | 
|
The Detective | SAFE | VOTE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | DEAD | |||
| 5th | Nikita Dragun | 
|
The Troublemaker | SAFE | SAFE | VOTE | SAFE | SAFE | DEAD | ||||
| 6th | JC Caylen | 
|
The Hippie | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | DEAD | ||||||
| 7th | Teala Dunn | 
|
The Super Spy | SAFE | SAFE | DEAD | |||||||
| 8th | Manny MUA | 
|
The Record Producer |
SAFE | DEAD | ||||||||
- █ The guest escaped the night.
- █ The guest was resurrected back from the dead and was safe.
- █ The guest went into a team challenge, won and saved their teammate from dying.
- █ The guest went into a team challenge but failed to save their teammate.
- █ The guest was ineligible for vote and was safe.
- █ The guest was voted into a challenge, won and survived.
- █ The guest was cursed and was automatically competing in a challenge, won and survived.
- █ The guest was voted into a challenge, lost and died.
- █ The guest was forced into a challenged due to failing a task, lost and died.
- █ The guest died due to the guests betraying him/her..
- █ the guest was not voted into a challenge but died with a plot twist
- █ The guest was voted into a challenge and survived along with his/her challenger.
How They Died[]
- Manny Mua - Stabbed in the stomach repeatedly by head clown.
- Teala Dunn - Bitten and poisoned by the Snake Woman.
- JC Caylen - Strangled and gassed by The Man with No Name.
- Roi Fabito - Beaten to death by The Strong Man, but was resurrected in Episode 7.
- Nikita Dragun - Locked into the Maiden of Madness and bled out.
- Matthew Patrick - Slashed out the stomach with a fish hook by Willie.
- Colleen Ballinger - Stabbed by the Witches as a sacrifice.
- Rosanna Pansino- Shot 6 times by Roi Fabito.