Lele Pons, nicknamed The Hustler was invited by Joey Graceffa to attend dinner at his Estate, that you could only find in the 1920s, which he had just inherited. At the very beginning, she starts a season-long feud with Matt Haag. She is voted into the Ungodly Machine Challenge, and chooses Eva Gutowski to be her partner. She was up against Andrea Brooks and her partner, Justine Ezarik. Eva manages to save her from The Ungodly Machine and they retrieve the first of four Artifacts. She is then voted to play Perverse Games with Joey. It then turns out that they were safe and had to betray someone else by writing their name in the murder. She desperately wants to kill Matt, but Joey refuses and put’s GloZell Green’s name down, killing her. Later, she is voted into the Ring Toss Challenge, and is forced to pick a partner of the opposite gender, and is forced to pick Joey, since the only other male still alive, Oli White, was in the challenge as well. Oli then chooses Eva. Eva manages to save Oli first, causing Lele to be electrocuted to death. Sometime after this, her soul is collected by The Collector and stored in the Jar of Souls. Her soul is later freed by Joey, Bretman Rock, and Colleen Ballinger.
Episode 1 - An Invitation
She is the second to last guest to arrive at the mansion followed shortly by Timothy. After Joey makes his grand entrance, she is seen having drinks with him, Oli, Andrea, and Sierra in the foyer, asking Joey if he owns the house, saying in her confessional she needs to be apart of it because "it's just big". After saying he does not have the deed yet she responds with "so you're not rich", before he mentions he will be signing the deed tonight.
Episode 2 - The Ungodly Machine
Episode 3 - Buried Alive
Episode 4 - Mannequins
Lele is voted into Peverse Games with Joey. It was then revealed that the two of them would have to betray one of their friends, killing them. Lele insisted on killing Matt, but Joey promised that he would convince Matt not to vote her as they built a bond over the course of the challenge. Joey then, against Lele's will, voted GloZell, killing her.
Episode 5 - Freak Show
Lele yet again votes against Matt, she tells him that he is going to heaven when he says that he won't vote for her.
Episode 6 - Did Someone Call For An Exorcist?
Episode 7 - Mermaid Tails
Lele goes swimming with Joey to recover the dead bodies and a locked chest. After the group unlock the chest, it says 2 guests need to be voted into the final death challenge to retrieve the doll in which, Lele convinces the group to vote Matthew Haag into the challenge, which everyone agrees with her on as he has given up on helping, after Sierra died, and cheers Timothy after he manages to defeat Matt, killing him.
Episode 8 - All Out War
Lele votes Eva into the challenge, knowing Eva could handle the consequences and win against whomever is voted into the Challenge. Eva is chosen, and to Lele's relief, comes back out alive.
Episode 9 - Wicked Hallucinations
When she suggests for everyone to vote for themselves in the final death challenge as she likes them all, Lele, along with the remaining guests, votes herself into the Final Challenge. She and Oli are picked, after she is told that they have to pick partners of opposite genders to fight for them, and Lele is left with no choice but to pick Joey, which she is quite unhappy about. After Joey fails to rescue Lele in the Ring Toss Challenge, she is electrocuted and is the last person to be killed.
Episode 10 - The Carnival Master (Episode)
Lele's death is shown in the Carnival Master's crystal.
|Episode||Voted For||Did She Go Into The Challenge|
|The Ungodly Machine||Matt Haag||Yes|
|Buried Alive||Justine Ezarik||No|
|Freak Show||Matt Haag||No|
|Did Someone Call For An Exorcist?||Matt Haag||No|
|Mermaid Tails||Matt Haag||No|
|All Out War||Eva Gutowski||No|
- "Matt wasn't doing anything. He was just standing there."
- ”Are we not gonna call the police for this?!?”
- "This is like Saw!"
- "Joey, we have to!"
- "I think we should kill Matt."
- "Aw! You're going to heaven."
- "You guys are sick."
- "I’m so happy I’m not the only one yelling at Matt and Eva is taking over.”
- "I wouldn't mind getting stuck for a hundred years with this guy." - Lele falling in love with Collin.
- ”All the hate was on Matt.”
- "I hate that basement."
- "Joey, please try. You're not trying!" - Lele’s final words.
- "I'm getting super pissed at Joey. He's literally throwing it on my feet!"
- "If I was a guy, I would have gotten the biggest boner!" - Reaction to Collin.
- Lele was asked to return for Season 4 but never responded.
- She was the first guest to suggest everyone to vote for themselves.
- She was the first person to start a rivalry between another guest.