Joey Graceffa was plagued by nightmares of a house built without hands, a house that was built by evil itself. Soon after, he recieved a letter telling him that it was his. He happily moved into The Estate, which only existed in the 1920’s, unaware that it was being possessed by The Evil, and that the staff, Arthur, Sarah, and Marvin were all evil as well. His nightmares continued, untill he decided to invite his friends, along with giving them a persona to match. He chose his own persona to be The Savant. He chose to invite Oli White, Eva Gutowski, Lele Pons, Timothy DeLaGhetto, Matt Haag, Sierra Furtado, GloZell Green, Justine Ezarik, Andrea Brooks, and Shane Dawson. Everything seems normal until Shane is poisoned. The group is tasked with creating an antidote, but they fail, and Shane succumbs to the poison and dies. After searching his body, they learn about The Evil, and that they only had one night to escape the Estate, or else they would be trapped in the 1920’s. But the only way to do so were to vote in two who would partake in a deadly challenge, and collect Cursed Artifacts. They would have to follow clues marked by the Society Against Evil. Later, he was one of the only people to defend Justine, who was being targetted by the group as the traitor, and wanted to bury her alive. In the end, his convincing wasn’t enough and Justine was killed. GloZell blamed him for what was going on, believing him to be the traitor. This result in him being voted in to play Perverse Games with Lele. However, instead of one of them dying, they were forced to kill someone else. Joey chooses to kill GloZell, and she chokes on her blood. Later, Joey is tasked with saving Lele from the Ring Toss Challenge, fighting against Oli and Eva. He ultimately fails to save Lele and she is electrocuted to death. They find out about Arthur and the rest of the staff being evil, and work to defeat them. When the other two remaining guests, Oli and Eva, are distracted, Joey secretly takes the dead to the estate. They perform the binding ritual, beliving that they had banished the evil. They then bury the artifacts right as dawn is breaking. However, The Evil never truly went away, taking refuge inside the cracks of Joey’s soul. The Evil, now having power over Joey, transported him to the Victorian Era. Joey discovers the Victorian Mansion, before collapsing as The Evil throws itself out of his body, and awakening The Sorceress. The Sorceress then takes control of Joey’s body, and uses him to invite more friends to the Victorian Era. The Sorceress invited Tyler Oakley, Andrea Russett, Alex Wassabi, Gabbie Hanna, Tana Mongeau, Liza Koshy, DeStorm Power, Jesse Wellens, and Lauren Riihimaki. Joey was then handed off to the Vampires to be feasted upon. He and Liza worked together to free each other, and Joey found his bearings. However, he soon found himself in another night of death. They discovered that they had to retrieve 8 Gems and locate The Crown Of Oblivion, and of course, each time they wanted a gem, someone had to die. However, they had the help of a vampire princess named Alison. Joey breaks his alliance with Liza halfway through the night and votes her into one of the challenges, and she dies. He is then voted to walk The Path of Betrayal with Andrea. Once again, he is forced to betray one of his friends. Andrea uses process of elimination to decide on Tana, in which Joey agrees. Tana dies due to their betrayal. He is then forced to run The Gauntlet against Tyler, Andrea, and Alex. He almost loses, but finishes in third place. Andrea fails the challenge, but Alison sacrifices her life so Andrea can live. He is then chosen by Alex to be his partner, but ultimately fails him and Alex is killed. The last remaining guests get the crown and all of the gems, but have been tricked by the Sorceress, who was only using them to recollect the crown so that she could use it herself. She begins her evil plan, but is stopped when Joey, Tyler, and Andrea break all three Leviathan Seals and free Riley. Joey believes the Sorceress is dead, but is tricked and stabbed twice in a desperate attack from her. The Sorceress is then killed with the same blade that killed Joey at the hands of Riley. Before Tyler and Andrea leave, they lay Joey to rest and leave the Crown of Oblivion on his head. This causes him to wake up in The World Between Worlds. He is confronted by the Society Against Evil, who offer him a proposition. Save the Town of Everlock from The Carnival Master and he’ll be revived. Sounds simple. Except he has to willing invite more friends to die. He accepts the conditions and signs the contract. This time, he brings Matthew Patrick, Nikita Dragun, Manny MUA, Rosanna Pansino, Safiya Nygaard, Colleen Ballinger, Teala Dunn, Roi Fabito, and JC Caylen along with him. They meet Calliope and Mortimer afterwards. Soon after, they discover the mysterious Lazarus Box. Halfway through the night, he is forced to reveal his secret to the group after being pressured by Matt, Colleen, and Safiya. Most of the group don’t take the fact that he willing brought them here to die lightly, especially Matt and Colleen. However, Matt’s sudden death shocks the group to it’s core. Colleen is sick of Joey and wants him gone, having lost all trust in him. But that was her biggest mistake, and when the group had to sacrifice someone to The Maiden of Madness, every single one of them voted for her, most of them flat out telling her they voted for her. She begged and screamed for them to stop but it was too late, and she was killed. With the group’s morale at an all time low, they needed some hope. They could finally unlock the Lazarus Box, and retrieve the Harp of Lazarus, which had the power to bring one of their friends from the dead. Joey chooses to revive Matt, and he returns from the dead. Matt tells Joey he saw what Joey saw, and that Joey was telling the truth. Joey is later forced into The Cursed Challenge due to being cursed. He, along with Matt and Nikita, defeat the Carnival Master, which brings Joey back to life. He leaves the group for a moment, knowing that the Crystal in the Carnival Master’s chest was a gift from the Society Against Evil. He sees the faces of his dead friends within, and hears Liza call for help. He then realizes he can save his dead friends. He recruits Matt and Nikita, and have them collect important objects. Matt goes for the Crown of Oblivion, and Nikita locates the Carnival Master’s Crystal. Joey returns to the original estate and digs up the buried artifacts. Nikita invites Bretman Rock on the mission, which he isn’t pleased about. They then talk about their plan to open a portal to Purgatory and sneak into the Museum of the Dead, which was owned by The Collector, who had collected the guest’s souls for her modern exhibit. They open the portal, but only Joey and Bretman make it through. He discovers The YouTuber Exhibit, which held Justine, Timothy, DeStorm, Tana, Gabbie, Alex, Colleen, and Ro inside glass cases. He broke the magic keeping them hostage, overjoyed that they were once again free. But most of them weren’t happy to see Joey. However, they were soon attacked by The Collector’s Guards and split up. They reunite with The Sorceress and Mortimer, who offer their help. They learn that they had no way out and that they had to collect 9 Jeweled Keys to unlock The Collector’s Vault and obtain The Cosmic Sphere, which would help them escape Purgatory. He slowly rekindles his friendship with Colleen, gaining her trust. Mortimer is killed a second time. Later, Matt and Nikita gain temporary access to Purgatory. However, Matt soon teleports back right before Colleen is killed for a second time, which Joey is heartbroken over. Joey then chooses to take Alex’s place in The Story Challenge, as he had already been in two challenges. After the challenge, Nikita is teleported back as well. Then, The Genie let’s them revive one friend. The votes were between Colleen and Tana, but Joey ultimately chooses Colleen, who is split on her opinion about being revived, as she could die again. Joey is then forced into The Pirate's Blood Challenge against Bretman and Alex. Alex loses, and is shot. Joey thanks Alex for all he did for the group before he dies. Later, he, along with Bretman and Colleen, discover the Soul Jar, which contained the rest of the spirits that hadn’t been added to the YouTuber Exhibit. The Collector showed herself, having returned from an expedition for more exhibits. She fights with The Sorceress, and is ultimately killed. Joey and the group are relieved, but The Sorceress turns on them, usurping the museum. However, the Collector is revived, telling them that her soul can’t leave and will always return to her body. She brings back previous monsters, such as Sam, one of the Vampires, the blue Harpy, High Tower, Benjamin, Lucy, and The Carnival Master, who chase after Joey and the others. Joey obtains the Sword Of All Legends, which he uses to turn the Collector to stone, and takes The Collector's Key. Once Joey unlocks the Collector’s Vault, he discovers the Cosmic Sphere and Pandora's Box. He is entranced by the box, but Colleen and Bretman pull him away. He then goes and frees everyone trapped in the Soul Jar. Bretman uses the sphere to open a portal to freedom, but Joey runs away. He goes back to Pandora’s Box and opens it, which releases a red gas, causing Joey to convulse in pain. He is then turned to smoke, and sucked up into Pandora’s Box, which locks him inside.
Episode 1 - An Invitation
The episode starts out with a monologue of Joey, describing the house and how it 'won't let him sleep until he invites others'. He writes out a letter to his friends, inviting them to the estate. As the group of invited guests gets to the mansion, they all are greeted by Joey and he welcomes them to drinks and then dinner in The Dining Room. When the group settles down for dinner, they notice that both Shane and Eva are gone, and Joey states in a following confessional that he believes it was rude of them to go explore, especially when he told them not to. When they two return, Joey (along with a majority of the group) keep questioning them and wonder why they both keep changing the subject. When Arthur hands Shane a telegram, the group (Joey included) gets curious and demands for him to read it out loud. Finding out that he was poisoned, most of the group sifts the blame on Joey and believes that he was the one who poisoned Shane. After they discover that they need three vials to make an antidote for Shane within 15 minutes, Joey helps find a vial along with GloZell and Eva, finding the key in a painting for unlocking the first (and only unlocked) vial in a painting. People start blaming Joey for poisoning Shane again, in the aftermath of his passing. But Joey finds a note in Shane's coat and the group learns about the Society Against Evil, and that Shane was a member of it.
Episode 2 - The Ungodly Machine
Joey leads the guests in finding the clues with the symbols on it. He helps find the books that unlock the Glassed Hand. Joey also helps coordinate the chess game chess to find a new clue, that being to find objects around the house that have to do with Fire, Water, Air and Earth to unlock the cabinet in The Ballroom. Joey was in the Water group. After they unlock the cabinet, they have to vote for two guests to go into The Basement. Joey, along with Eva, Justine, and Sierra, votes for Andrea to go. Joey's afraid that people are going to go after him because he invited all of them to the mansion. After they come back from the basement, they have an artifact, Oli finds a note alluding to one of the guests working with the evil of the house, and most are split between Joey and Justine.
Episode 3 - Buried Alive
Many people believe Justine is working with the evil, after she failed to save Andrea from The Ungodly Machine. Joey, Matt and Justine all vote for Tim, while everyone else voted for Justine. Justine's name was pulled, she tried to run away but was grabbed by Marvin. Joey tried to stop the group from burying her but he fails after, GloZell holds him while he has to watch Justine die. He refuses to take part burying her.
Episode 4 - Mannequins
At voting, Lele and Joey are voted into the challenge, for Perverted Games. It is revealed that GloZell voted Joey in, as she says that since it is his house, he has to know what is going on, so he is the evil one. At the end of the challenge, it is revealed that Joey and Lele must write a name down in a death journal, killing them. Lele wants to write down Matt, but Joey insists on writing down GloZell's name, and says that he will make sure that Matt doesn't vote for Lele in the future. Despite Lele not having a say in this, Joey writes GloZell's name down in the death journal thus killing GloZell. They hear the guests shouting downstairs, and Joey begs for Lele not to tell the group about the betrayal. Lele eventually confesses.
Episode 5 - Freak Show
Episode 6 - Did Someone Call For An Exorcist?
Episode 7 - Mermaid Tails
Episode 8 - All Out War
Episode 9 - Wicked Hallucinations
Joey fails to save Lele from the ring toss challenge, resulting Lele Pons's death.
Episode 10 - Betrayal At The House On The Hill
Joey takes the deed to the house.
Episode 1 - The Masquerade Part I
Joey is possessed by the sorceress and she had joey to invite 9 youtubers seek the Crown of oblivion he is then found tied up while vampires feast on him
Episode 2 - The Masquerade Part II
Joey is accused by Destorm of being the Evil Joey
Episode 3 - Tangled Web
Episode 4 - A Nation Divided
Episode 5 - The Gingerbread Woman
Episode 6 - Endless Winter Night
The group is sitting in The Green Room when Alex begins to express his disbelief towards Liza's death. Andrea then begins to blame Joey, saying that if he hadn't turned on her, she would still be alive. Joey, afterward, begins to blame Tyler, saying that because he is here and she isn't, it's his fault. In the midst of the argument, Alex exclaims that they can't fight like this and that it's what The Sorceress wants them to do. They begin to discuss how many more gems they need to get, and the scroll they were given by Sampson, which reads:
Then they realize that hearth means fireplace, so Joey and Alex begin to push aside the bricks and find the compass. Beginning to examine the compass, they discover another note, which reads:
They begin looking in the cupboard until Joey finds the spell book. They then find a page with the instructions to perform the spell to enter the other realm.
The groups eventually split up into two teams.
Joey and the girls enter the room and discover a tray full of blood, where they need to find the correct vial of blood. They find a clipboard with various patients' names and begin to go down the list to find the vial of blood, continuing to search while the others wait downstairs. They finally find the correct vial of blood and go downstairs to the others. Andrea reads out the spell.
As soon as they have finished, the circle lights up along with the compass, as a voice tells them that the compass will grow brightest when they move in the right direction. They are then led outside, which teleports them to the different realm. A woman is standing in front of the group. She then turns around and sees them, saying that the heroes of their prophecy have arrived. She explains that her world has been cursed by the evil Ice Witch. She continues and tells them the only way to defeat her is to find The Unquenchable Fire. They must find it on The Path of Betrayal. To get to the path, they must find the Harpy Talisman and that they must have a brave hero who can help them defeat the evil Harpies, who guard it. The woman continues saying that Torhil to the Undying was such a great warrior and that the last spell in her book should be able to reverse the Ice Witch's curse.
They begin looking around and Joey finds the flute which tells him to play the right note to summon the Fairy. He plays the note correctly and the Fairy is summoned. After she is summoned, the group tells the Fairy that they need her tears, and although hesitant at first, agrees to it as long as someone can make her laugh. The group ends up getting her to laugh and she begins to cry, giving them a vial with her tears inside of it. After a little searching, Alex finds the scepter and they are ready to perform the spell. It then tells them to put the scepter in front of Torhil and sprinkle the fairy tears in his eyes then move back 20 paces before reading the spell.
Episode 7 - Automaton Love Story
The group all decide to vote for themselves, and Alex and Gabbie are picked for the final death challenge, to get one of their hearts used in a robot, to serve as a wife for Cedric. Alex wins the challenge, and Gabbie's heart is used for the bride. Joey says this is kind of cute, and Cedric is a romantic.
Episode 8 - Full Moon Slaughter
Joey is seen waiting with the others in the lounge for midnight to come which is in less than five minutes. Finally, midnight arrives and a chest opens with a note from The Sorceress, reading as follows:
Then, suddenly, a man starts pounding on the door, terrifying all of them. Alex decides they should open the doors and try to help the man. He then runs into the lounge and says that he needs their help and that his son is going to die if they don't do something. He then explains that they were attacked by werewolves, startling everyone. Allison then asks why that was. He explains that he took a gem from them, showing the group. He then says that if they save his son, he will give the gem to them. They then all agree to help him for the gem and follow him outside, with lanterns to find Quicksilver and Wolfsbane to cure his son. They are then told that there is a map down, near the fountain, where they can find the Wolfsbane. They arrive at the fountain and start looking around to find a chest. They find out that they need to find 3 keys to get the map, which is inside the chest. Joey then begins to grab plant pots and smash them on the ground trying to find the keys. Joey, shortly after, finds one of the keys in the fountain. Then, Tyler finds another one of the keys in a plant pot. Andrea suddenly finds the third key in another plant pot. They unlock the chest and begin to read the map, when a werewolf comes out of nowhere and tries to attack the group, which they fortunately escape from. They then find a carriage with a chest inside it, this time with a combination. It says that only the horses can see immediately. Everyone pretends to be a horse to try and figure out the clue. They find blinders, which answers the clue. They now have the Wolfsbane. They find another note.
They start walking when Joey discovers the safe. On it, there is another note.
They make the decision to split up into three groups. Alex and Andrea go to the greenhouse, Joey and Tyler take the stone path and Allison along with Atticus check for the one that was where they were. If a werewolf came, they had to hide else they'd be taken. Joey and Tyler, while walking the path, form an alliance. They find a mutilated rabbit, which they need to dig into to find their next clue. They find a scroll and begin to read, though are interrupted by the werewolf. They successfully hide and finish reading the note afterward.
The group finds a trap which lowers a bag full of items, including a belt full of bullets. They count how many there are. They get 11, Allison's and Atticus' get 13 while Andrea and Alex get 27. Tyler suggests that they should split the numbers down the middle, and it works. They now have the 2 items required to heal the Atticus' son. They reach his son and have to put the Quicksilver and Wolfsbane in a mix and put it over his wound. The boy warns them that they need to run, because his father is a werewolf. They are surrounded by him and another werewolves. Allison demands he give them the gem, because they did what he wanted. The group is then told that they have to run the gauntlet, which is a 4 part obstacle course. Whoever finishes last will be devoured by the werewolves. Allison, after Andrea loses, sacrifices herself so they can get away with the gem. They then go down the red hallway. The elevator opens and the Devourer comes out running after them.
Episode 9 - The Dark Dimension
At voting, the group decides to all vote for themselves. Alex and Andrea are picked, and Alex picks Joey, leaving Andrea with Tyler. The group must enter The Dark Dimension to find the final gem. Andrea finds the final gem in The Dark Dimension, causing Alex to die in this episode
Episode 10 - The Sorceress
Joey, along with Tyler and Andrea, finds the Crown of Oblivion and realizes that they can finally escape. Shortly afterward, The Sorceress revives all the lieutenants and the remaining guests run for their lives. They find clues to the spell while The Sorceress is outside doing magic with the gems and the crown which she stole from them. All of a sudden, her magic stops working and she becomes weaker and weaker, gradually.
The guests then find Riley, who is believed to be a good part of The Sorceress. She starts running to get vengeance from The Sorceress. The guests re-unite with Jetpack Girl there. Joey, Tyler and Andrea catch up to her and find The Sorceress lying there, weak, with the Crown of Oblivion. Joey, who realizes that they can escape now grabs the crown. Unfortunately, The Sorceress, conscious again, stabs Joey in the chest with a knife. All of a sudden, Riley takes the knife from The Sorceress and murders her as well. Tyler and Andrea realize that the game is over and the good has won. Tyler grabs the crown carefully and wears it which gets rid of the evil in the house. Upset, Andrea and Tyler put Joey's body and the Crown of Oblivion on top of his chest in a casket. Tyler and Andrea then finally escape. Back in the casket, the crown glows and Joey is resurrected, gasping, which marks the end of Season 2.
Episode 1 - The Clowns Here Kill Part 1
A recap begins, telling us from Joey's perspective that he believed he had finally defeated the evil for good this time and that he thought he was going home, but that he was wrong. He had died. His soul went to the world between worlds, where he was confronted by two members of the Society Against Evil. They tell him that they have a way for him to get back, but that his friends will have to die. One of them gives him a blade which he cuts himself with and begins to bleed. They then give him a contract and a bag, saying that the contract binds him to Everlock and that if he saves the town he shall return to the living, and that if he fails he will be lost amongst the dead forever.
He then writes letters to all of his friends telling them that he's going on an extraordinary adventure and that he needs their help and so do hundreds of others (the people of Everlock). Joey had his friends meet him at a fireplace in the middle of the woods just before they are about to leave Joey arrives his friends all begin to ask him what is going on and are excited to see him he tells them he doesn't know much about how to get to the town he opens the backpack that the SAE gave him with a scroll, salt and five crystals. The instructions tell them how to enter the town of Everlock.
They are then told to all hold hands and chant the following phrase.
They then notice a bridge in the distance with a sign saying Town of Everlock. They walk towards it when a Killer Clown comes out from behind a curtain, shocking the guests who nearly all jump back in shock. She then tells them that it's their lucky day because the carnival is in town. She goes on to explain that they have a strong man, a snake woman, and dolls with knives (which are referring to future guardians). The clown then says that they will all be "friends" soon and that she has a good feeling about it and she then opens the curtain telling them to enjoy the ride.
The group all enters the carnival with many of the guests wondering what there is to actually save when suddenly they begin screaming when they see a woman with a spider in her mouth crawling alongside her cheek. They all begin to eat and play carnival games and they begin to show confusion toward what they have to do here. Then, a woman comes up to them, saying that the stars have been talking to her and telling her all kinds of secrets. The guests are confused and ask what type of secrets she tells them that he is coming, everyone confused at who the woman is referring to.
It then pans to a Ferris Wheel, where Rosanna and Matthew decide to go ride it together. There is a blanket on the bench, and underneath the blanket is a newspaper which has a picture of 4 clowns, one of them being the clown that welcomed them into Everlock. Suddenly, the ride stops with both Matt and Rosanna stuck at the top of the Ferris Wheel. Due to the instability of the ride, leaning forward increases their chances of falling off. They try to warn their friends but nobody can hear them from below.
The clown that welcomed them into town approaches Joey and Teala and invites them over to a game. She explains that if they shoot all the cans down, they win a prize. They decide to play and win a Jack in the Box. The clown then tells them not to open it just yet. The group surrounds Joey, and he and Teala explain what it is. Some of them are saying he should open it, while others say not to open it, when suddenly a horn blares, scaring all of the guests.
Mayor Janet comes out and begins to thank everyone for coming to the carnival, saying it's their lifeblood, when the woman from earlier disagrees, saying that she thinks she means sucking our blood. She then says that the spell won't last forever, and You-Know-Who will be back. The mayor says not to listen to her, and that she is gypsy trash from the outskirts of town, not to be trusted. She then looks at Joey and asks him where he got the Jack-In-A-Box. He tells her that he won it and it's his when she asks him if he knows what that is. Both the group and the mayor tell her it's just a music box and a toy. She tells him that it is one of The Carnival Master's wicked artifacts. The mayor then tells Joey to open it to 'put this woman's hysteria to rest'.
He does as told, and out of the box comes a figure dead clown with swords in its head, the group also hearing screams along with it. From behind the mayor, a clown slowly creeps up behind her, hoists her up and drops her from the balcony making her fall to her death. Suddenly, clowns begin to attack the carnival, killing people as the group begins to make a run for the arcade, along with Mortimer.
However, not all of them make it in time and Roi, Colleen, and Joey are kidnapped and taken to the Clown's RV. The clown from earlier takes Joey to the van and says that The Carnival Master will be released at sunrise and that the whole town is going to burn. She then licks his cheek, leaving a smudge of lipstick on it. They realize that all of them are handcuffed in different spots of the RV and that they need to solve riddles in order to get out of the RV.
Episode 2 - The Clowns Here Kill Part 2
Episode 3 - Venomous Affections
Episode 4 - The Man with No Name
Episode 5 - Strong Like A Demon
Episode 6 - Twin Dolls
Episode 7 - Funhouse
Joey is confused when Willie enters the 'safe' lounge. He kills Safiya, and Manny and Nikita both come back from the death challenge.
Episode 8- Wicked Witches
Episode 9- Control Issues
Joey has a flashback of one of the society against evil tells him that the carnival master has a crystal that has the power to bring the dead from his past and present back
Episode 10- The Carnival Master (Episode)
Joey tells Matt and Nikita that he needs to do something. He then goes to The Carnival Master and rips the crystal out of his chest. When he looks inside and sees all the people who died because of him and Liza tells him that all of the dead guests are in danger.
Episode 1- Collecting the Dead: Part 1
Joey, Matthew Patrick, and Nikita Dragun officially join the Society Against Evil, coming up with the plan to rescue their dead friends from the Museum of the Dead, which is located in Purgatory. The three of them briefly go on their own missions to collect important items from the series, with Joey going after the Season 1 Artifacts and digging them up after he, Oli, and Eva had originally buried them. Matt goes and finds The Crown Of Oblivion from Season 2, while Nikita holds onto the Carnival Master’s Crystal from Season 3. Joining them on their rescue mission are Jael and Ryu. Nikita then reveals that she invited Bretman Rock along to help them, which Joey is upset with, not wanting to put anyone else in danger.
He and Bretman avoid The Collector’s Guards that The Collector had released while she was busying gathering new exhibits from the Town of Everlock, taking The Gorgon with her. They slip by and come across the glass cases keeping all of his friends trapped. He then uses a pickaxe to break the spell that was keeping them there, freeing them. However, some of the guests (especially Colleen) don’t respond positively to seeing him again, blaming him for all their deaths. Later on, he gets split up from the group, along with Bretman and Gabbie, and attempts to free Alex, Rosanna, Colleen and Justine from a cage.
Episode 2 - The Museum of Death: Part 2
Joey and the group enter the Sands of Egypt and meets the former wife of the Pharaoh. He soon learns that the Pharaoh's ex wife is the reason why it's disturbed in the first place and witnesses The Sorceress killing her with a knife.
Later on, he and the group begin deciding on who to send into the challenge. When Justine and Tana's cards are pulled, he felt bad for them, but also knew that Justine was more likely come back instead of Tana. When Justine and Tana go into the challenge, Colleen continues to blame Joey and is still convinced that it's his fault that their in this situation in the first place. Joey tries to tell her that this was not his intention and that "things happen". Just then, Tana comes back from the challenge with the Mummy's Jeweled Key. Joey is shocked about Tana being the victor and Justine being killed for the second time.
Episode 3 - A Deal With A Demon
When distributing coins among the group, Joey gives some of his coins to Colleen (rekindling their friendship and trust for one another).
Episode 4 - A Wedding To Die For
Joey was captured along with the other males and was forced to find a spear, but in order to do that they had to complete 4 tasks (Joey completing the second task).
Episode 5 - Dark Magic and A Twisted Fate
Everyone (except Colleen) votes for Joey. Despite the five votes against him, he is not voted into the challenge and Tana and Gabbie's cards are chosen instead. Wanting to save both of their friends, Joey and the group leave the lounge to help Tana and Gabbie, only to see them both get killed by the Black Knight instead. When they return to the lounge, with the Jeweled Key, Joey grows suspicious of the group (except Colleen) due to them voting him in.
Episode 6 - The Maze of Terror
Alex is captured when trying to prove himself to the group. Joey goes with Nikita and Bretman to help save him. Nikita is up first, and knocks the first of three gates down, but then caught by The Minotaur, and brought to the cage where Alex is being held. Bretman is up next, he knocks the second gate down, and is then caught and brought to the cage as well. Joey realises that it is up to him to save his friends. He knocks the third gate down, and finds out that he can either vote for himself, or cause his friends in the cage to automatically have one vote. He chooses to vote for himself. Colleen and Alex are chosen for the final death challenge, and Joey is devastated when he finds out that his closest friend, Colleen, has died.
Episode 7 - Be Careful What You Wish For
- "I Guess She Didn't Watch my video..."
- "THIS IS SICK!"
- "You didn't buy my act?"
- "It's my party and I can kill whoever I want to"
- "Cedric is kind of a romantic. He has a heart... I guess, two hearts... "
- "Oh, let's see how the devil's doing." In response to Tyler saying they have to call hell.
- "She just killed her best friend!"
- "So Willie comes waltzing into our lounge, our supposedly safe lounge."
- "I'm voting for Teala for the 3rd time... huh, the 3rd time [that all of Teala's cards were taken]. How is she still alive?"
- "If they find out my secret, I'm ruined."
- "The truth is... I died."
- "You wanna go say hi to Colleen?"
- "You Guy's Get What I Asked For?"-Joey Talking to Matt and Nikita
- "I thought I was on a rescue mission but turns out I'm on a rescue mission to save my own ass!"
- "Please. Alex is as much evil as I am straight."
- "Matt! NIkita!" Joey re-uniting with the Season 3 survivors
- Out of all of the seasons, Joey has been entered into six challenges. And out of all six of those challenges, his life was only truly in danger twice. Two of the challenges he had to betray someone, the other Alison sacrificed herself for the loser, and in the other Fatima would kill Scheherazade no matter who was in the challenge. The only challenges he could’ve potentially died in were the Cursed Challenge and The Pirate’s Blood Challenge.
- Season 3 is the only season where Joey was never voted into a challenge.
- On Twitter, Joey stated that users can tweet at him to vote for dead guests to return.
- As of Season 3 Joey has killed a total of 29 people. 22 guests, 3 helpers, 1 unnamed solider, and 3 vampires/enemies. Congratulations.
- The two times Joey was picked as someone's partner for the final challenge of the season, his partner died.
- Joey is the only guest to have the same role in every season he has appeared in, being called the Savant, no matter the time period.
- Fans have gotten very upset because of him NEVER going into a death challenge (Where he could actually die) through votes. Proof of it is that in Season 2, Episode 5, there were several votes towards his name but Liza and Tyler ended up going in. Same applies for Tana and Gabbie in Season 4, Episode 5. (Plot shields are the worst shields, Joey...)
- Joey is the only guest to volunteer himself into a challenge after the voting was already complete
- Joey is the Second Guest to physically kill someone, with him killing the Vampire he would later be followed by Matthew Patrick DeStorm Power and Colleen Ballinger