Arthur is the butler of the mansion and a secondary antagonist in season 1 of Escape the Night. It was revealed in Wicked Hallucinations that Arthur was in league with the evil of the house, the entire time. He also has a brother that he tied up in the basement to gain favor with the evil.
Theory
Three of the six original names in the Death Journal sound familiar:
- Arthur Fletcher
- Sarah Hayes
- Marvin Jones

Is Arthur Fletcher the butler?